Case study: Payne’s Pecans finds hidden product defects with X-ray inspection

The company recently started using WECO’s Multiscan MXV-Bulk X-ray inspection system to improve product quality, increase throughput and reduce reliance on hand sorting.

Key Highlights

  • Payne’s Pecans became the first in North America to install the MXV-Bulk X-ray system for pecan inspection, focusing on internal defect detection.
  • The system analyzes density differences inside each nut to identify hidden defects and foreign materials, improving overall product quality.
  • Post-installation, the business saw an increase in grading scores from 40 to 44, translating to higher earnings per pound and better buyer confidence.
  • Operational efficiency improved significantly, with throughput increasing by 2,000 to 3,000 pounds per hour and only one person needed for final inspection.
  • The system is user-friendly and requires minimal daily maintenance, with excellent support from WECO, making it accessible for Payne’s without technical staff.

Payne’s Pecans is a family-owned pecan cleaning business that handles up to 2 million pounds of in-shell pecans annually for local growers. Founder Jay Payne has been around pecans since childhood, when he picked nuts from his family’s grove for Christmas money.

Since he opened Payne’s Pecans in Rich Hill, Missouri, in 2004, labor has become harder to find while buyers have grown more particular about product quality. Last year, Payne began using WECO’s Multiscan MXV-Bulk X-ray inspection system to improve product quality, increase throughput and reduce reliance on hand sorting.

“Inspection has always been one of the hardest parts of this business,” Payne said. “Finding several people to stand at a table and sort pecans by hand for hours is difficult enough, but there’s also only so much a person can catch by eye. We needed a better way to identify internal product defects.”

Payne’s became the first operation in North America to install an MXV-Bulk for pecan inspection. While optical sorters identify external characteristics such as color, size, shape and surface condition, the MXV-Bulk analyzes density differences inside each nut to identify hidden defects and insufficient kernel fill. The system also detects dense foreign material including stones, adding another layer of product protection before the pecans leave the facility.

At Payne’s, the MXV-Bulk sits near the end of the line, after pre-cleaning equipment has removed much of the lightweight debris and obvious foreign material. As the pecans pass through the inspection zone, a channel belt keeps them stable and evenly distributed for scanning. The system analyzes the X-ray images and triggers air valves to eject out-of-tolerance product.

“What surprised me most is what the system can detect that we simply couldn’t see before,” Payne said. “You can pick a pecan out of the reject stream, look at it and think there’s nothing wrong with it. Then you crack it open and find there’s little or no good nutmeat inside.”

For in-shell pecans, those hidden defects directly affect value. Buyers sample each lot, crack representative nuts and calculate the percentage of edible kernel. After installing the MXV-Bulk, Payne’s average grade increased from 40 to 44. “Buyers pay for what is inside the shell,” Payne said. “At 2 cents a point, going from a 40 to a 44 is another 8 cents a pound. On a big load, that adds up in a hurry.”

Consistency improved alongside grade. Payne’s A-grade lots now carry less than 1 percent lower-grade contamination, compared with the 2 to 3 percent the industry generally accepts.

“A machine evaluates every pecan the same way every time,” Payne said. “People get tired, and different people catch different things. Now, with our X-ray system, we’re getting much more consistent inspection. Buyers who have bought from me for years told me it was the best product they had seen come out of here.”

The operational gains have been equally significant. Before the X-ray system was installed, six to eight people inspected pecans by hand at the end of the line. Now, one person handles final inspection immediately after the MXV-Bulk, with very little left to remove. With inspection no longer constraining production, Payne estimates throughput has increased by 2,000 to 3,000 pounds per hour.

Despite the advanced technology, Payne says operating the system has been straightforward. Once the pecan settings were established, he has rarely needed to adjust the system, and daily cleaning consists primarily of wiping down the accessible belt. That simplicity matters for Payne, who does not have technical specialists on staff. “A lot of people hear X-ray and assume it’s going to be complicated, but we just turn it on and go to work,” Payne said.

“WECO has been great to partner with. It’s nice knowing I can pick up the phone and they’ll help me get things figured out. It feels like they’re part of our team,” Payne said. “With labor being what it is, I’m not sure I would have stayed in the pecan cleaning business if we hadn’t found a better way to handle inspection. That’s how much of a difference this system has made for us.”

About the Author

Cat McBride

Freelance writer

Cat McBride is a freelance writer focused on food processing and packaging topics.

Sign up for our eNewsletters
Get the latest news and updates